Back to Research

Migrant Inventors and the Technological Advantage of Nations

Dany Bahar, Prithwiraj Choudhury, Hillel Rapoport

Research Policy Vol. 49, No. 9 2020
View Publication
Visualization coming soon
Key visualization from Migrant Inventors and the Technological Advantage of Nations

Key Findings

  • A twofold increase in immigrant inventors from countries specializing in a technology raises the probability of the receiving country gaining technological advantage in that same technology by 25-60%
  • For the average country, this twofold increase corresponds to only about 25 inventors (standard deviation of 135)—a remarkably small number with large impact on national innovation trajectories
  • Results are driven by immigrant inventors, not emigrants—knowledge flows primarily from inventors' home countries to their receiving countries through the technology-specific expertise they bring
  • The effects hold for both OECD and non-OECD countries and are particularly strong during the 2000-2010 decade when global patenting activity accelerated
  • Results are robust across different patent databases (USPTO, EPO, PCT) and whether using patent applications or granted patents, ruling out 'home advantage' biases

About This Research

German and Austrian Jewish scientists who fled Nazi Germany in the 1930s famously boosted American innovation in chemistry—their fields of expertise. But does this pattern generalize? This paper investigates whether migrant inventors systematically help their receiving countries develop patenting capabilities in the same technologies where their home countries specialize.

Using patent data across 651 technology subclasses for 95 countries over two decades (1990-2010), combined with bilateral inventor migration data, we measure technological specialization using Revealed Technological Advantage (RTA). We examine both 'take-offs'—countries gaining advantage in entirely new technologies—and growth in technologies where they already have some activity. The results are striking: a small number of immigrant inventors can significantly reshape a country's innovation portfolio.

To establish causality, we employ two instrumental variable strategies: 30-year-old historical migration networks and predicted inventor flows based on push-pull factors. Multiple falsification tests—including randomizing inventor nationalities and examining inventors from countries without technological advantage—confirm that our results are driven by actual inventor presence transferring technology-specific knowledge, not pre-existing trends or spurious correlations.

innovation migration patents